dear amreshji,

Congratulations that you have written a two volume, 2000 page book on 1857, accepting it as  the first war of Indian Independence, but that  was with the British only.

A comprehensive study of history will suggestt that Maharana Pratap , Guru Govind  Singh, Chhatrpati shivaji were also fighting for the independence of country.

         True 1857 was not `Mutiny'  as called by the British.

                      We can feel the pain you have taken for a mammoth work and appreciate that.

           But whether that was for  fighting against RSS ? OK , then you assume RSS is worthy of acknowldging its intellectual frame work also.

. As a true Sanatani Hindu, you should be also ashamed on every onslughts on it since 712 AD if not before as that record is not well available.          

There is no question of 'upper caste intelligentsia' mania some persons advocate dividing Hindu society as Dalit, Adivasi,backward caste and what not.

          I also feel that attempt to partition this country again and that is by the same separatist forces which did 1947 partition and I am not to praise Jinnah for his work.

Hindu-Muslim unity  in the glare of terrorist inflammation world over is not possible till Islam itself rectifies its followeres who had been doing nacked violence world over(as did followers of Christ also).

"Unity in diversity," is a false slogan, "Idia is one and looks diverse," is fact and fact of unity is due to Hindu values which are sanatan.

 In a  non-colonial world  non-western path of development is irrelevant.

          Why you want accomplishment from Modi and Advani ?

You had rightly produced data in your book and that is appreciable.

            You are more offnsive to Modi than terrorists which is not right.

         True, "India needs a new infusion of blood--and that can only come from the persons who are not dividing society on the name of minorities, Adivasis, Dalits and backwards, etc.