A London court Tuesday sentenced a Briton to a minimum of 18 years in prison for the "racially-aggravated" murder of Indian Navy officer Kunal Mohanty in March 2009. Christopher Miller, 25, had knifed 30-year-old Mohanty in the neck as he walked to a restaurant with his friends in Glasgow.
Miller claimed in court that the incident was 'botched mugging' but a jury at the High Court in Glasgow returned a unanimous verdict of murder. The judge said the killing was as "incomprehensible as it was evil".
During the trial at the High Court in Glasgow prosecutors said the seaman was attacked because of his skin colour. Mohanty, who was due to become a father for the first time, was in Glasgow to sit his captain's exams at the city's Nautical College.
The court was told that he was left bleeding to death from an 18 cm long hole in his neck. A doctor described Mohanty's neck injury as "one of the worst he had ever seen". Prosecuting lawyer Dorothy Bain said it was "an atrocity delivered without mercy, a death blow" and "an unprovoked attack on a blameless, defenceless and wholly decent man because Christopher Miller didn't like the colour of his skin.
As Mohanty lay dying in the street with blood gushing from his neck, Miller and his friend John McGrory, 20, were seen on CCTV running through a car park celebrating.
Miller's brother Jamie Miller, 17, gave evidence during the trial and said Miller told him he had "done a Paki".
Sentencing him, temporary judge John Beckett told Miller: "Your behaviour after the murder suggested that you were anything but sorry and appeared to be celebrating".
"The murder was racially aggravated. There can be no justification for slashing the neck of someone who did you no harm... To do so because of the colour of a man's skin is as incomprehensible as it is evil," he said.
The judge said everyone in this city and this country should be ashamed of his actions. He told Miller that it would be up to the parole board to decide when he is released.
After the verdict, Lesley Thomson, area procurator fiscal for Glasgow said: "Mohanty was doing nothing other than enjoying time off his studies with friends. He was attacked for no reason other than that Christopher Miller is a racist".
"He died because Christopher Miller had a knife and had no hesitation in using it," she said.
She added that Glasgow rightly celebrates its cultural diversity and everyone should be free to enjoy the city in safety.
Det Insp Gary Thomson, the officer in charge of the investigation, said the racist murder of an innocent man on the streets caused a lot of concern and fear in the community, "however fortunately crimes of this nature aren't common".
"However one is still one too many, and the senseless loss of life is tragic," he said.
Press Trust of India, November 11, 2009, London
A man was jailed for life with a minimum term of 18 years yesterday after being convicted of murdering an Indian naval officer because of the colour of his skin.
Christopher Miller, 25, slashed Kunal Mohanty in the neck in an unprovoked attack as he was walking to a restaurant in Glasgow with friends.
Miller, who is unemployed, claimed that Mr Mohanty's death was the result of a robbery that went wrong. A jury at the High Court in Glasgow returned a unanimous verdict of racially aggravated murder.
Judge John Beckett, QC, described the crime as "as incomprehensible as it is evil".
Mr Mohanty, 30, whose wife was expecting their first child, was in Glasgow to sit his captain's exams at the city's Nautical College, where he had begun his studies 10 years earlier. He was murdered in the Gorbals area of the city as he headed to a fast food restaurant on the evening of March 27. A group, including Miller, approached him and asked him for a cigarette.
His friends, who were a few steps in front of him, told the trial that they had initially thought he was being sick, before realising that his neck was pouring with blood.
A casualty consultant who tried to save Mr Mohanty's life said that the 18cm knife wound inflicted by Miller was one of the worst injuries he had seen in 29 years of practice. The wound severed Mr Mohanty's carotid artery and jugular vein.
Dorothy Bain, QC, for the prosecution, described the attack as a "death blow" carried out on a "blameless, defenceless and wholly decent man because Christopher Miller didn't like the colour of his skin".
Miller, who has eight previous convictions for assault, robbery and carrying an offensive weapon, claimed that Mr Mohanty died when an attempted mugging went wrong and denied targeting him because of his race. He told police in a taped interview: "It was just a bit of robbery. I'm expecting him [Mr Mohanty] to see the blade but I don't know if he did."
Footage from closed-circuit television cameras positioned outside the procurator fiscal's office in the south of Glasgow told a different story. As Mr Mohanty lay dying in the street, Miller and his friend John McGrory, 20, were running through a car park celebrating. The men are seen cuddling, punching their arms in the air and at one point Miller pulls his jumper over his head in the manner of a footballer who has just scored a goal.
An hour later Miller was again recorded on CCTV throwing sauce at staff in an Asian takeaway restaurant, Sizzlers, and shouting racial abuse at them.
Miller's brother, Jamie Miller, 17, from Govanhill, Glasgow, gave evidence during the trial and said that Miller told him he had "done a Paki".
Donald Findlay, QC, for the defence, said Mr Mohanty's death "weighs heavily on [Miller's] mind", but Judge Beckett said that he could see no sign of remorse. "I can identify no or little mitigation," he said. "Your behaviour after the murder suggests that you were anything but sorry at the time. You went on to commit further crimes and appeared to celebrate them.
"There can be no justification for slashing the neck of a man who had done you no harm whatsoever."
Police and prosecutors welcomed Miller's conviction and warned that they would not tolerate the racial violence he had displayed.
Lesley Thomson, area Procurator Fiscal for Glasgow and Strathkelvin, said: "Racism has no place in our society; knife carriers have no place in our society; and people who act like Christopher Miller have no place in our society."
Detective Inspector Gary Thomson, who led the murder investigation, said: "The racist murder of an innocent man on our streets obviously caused a lot of concern and fear in the community. Strathclyde Police will not tolerate this type of racially motivated behaviour."
The Times, UK, November 11, 2009
